
Credit: Chaloner Woods/Stringer
That's funny, they don't look not Jewish.
As Hanukkah rolls on, we wondered who amongst the A-list crowd is celebrating. We know the obvious (Adam Sandler), the super-obvious (Steven Spielberg) and the super-duper obvious (Matisyahu). However, some of our assumptions didn't pan out. Just because someone looks Jewish--or has a Jewish-sounding last name--doesn't mean they had a bar or bat mitzvah. Here are 10 unexpected nonmembers of the tribe.
1. "Weird" Al Yankovic

Credit: Jason Merritt/Getty Images
That Eastern European mug suggests his in-flight meals are kosher, but alas, "Weird" Al is Serbian, English and Italian. He does not practice Judaism, despite what "Pretty Fly (For a Rabbi)" would have you believe.
2. Slash

Credit: Frank Micelotta/Stringer
Slash's real name is Saul Hudson, which makes him sound like a guy who always complains about the humidity in Florida. But nope, take it from the man himself: "I'm not Jewish! I'm 1/2 black, 1/2 British."
3. Lady Gaga

Credit: Scott Gries/Getty Images
Lady Gaga is outspoken and confident like a take-no-s**t citizen of Israel... but she wasn't born that way. Raised Roman Catholic, Gaga is totally not Jewish.
4. The Van Gundys

Credit: Jonathan Ferrey/Getty Images

Credit: Mike Ehrmann/Getty Images
The brothers remind us of bickering Jewish uncles at a family dinner. One is big and boisterous, the other is meek and chippy. Both, though, are 100% not Jewish.
5. Zooey Deschanel

Credit: Theo Wargo
We envisioned Deschanel as the hippie Orthodox chick in college who never went out on Friday nights 'cause of the Sabbath, but--like Gaga--she was raised Roman Catholic.
6. Michael Cera

Credit: Brendon Thorne/Stringer
Michael Cera is half Sicilian and half French-Canadian, according to Jonah Hill. (As for Jonah Hill? Total Jew.)
7. Michael Richards

Credit: Giulio Marcocchi/Stringer
Not only does Michael Richards look like a guy who owns a deli, he co-starred in the most Jewish sitcom ever. His true faith is a mystery, but it's not Judaism.
8. Tina Fey

Credit: Scott Gries/Getty Images
Tina Fey has a keen eye for humor and a blockbuster career in showbiz, but she's Greek Orthodox, which qualifies her as a shiksa goddess.
9. Andrew Schulz of "Guy Code"

Credit: TheAndrewSchulz.com
Andrew confirmed to us in a Facebook message: he's not Jewish. Hey, just because someone is a standup comedian born in New York, you can't make assumptions.
10. Jason Biggs

Wha-wha-what?!?
The hair, the face, the crude sense of humor... but no, Jason Biggs is the self-admitted "Jewiest looking non-Jew." He even fooled Woody Allen into thinking he was a nice Jewish boy. (We guess a real Jew would hump a bagel, not a pie.)
+ Follow Guy Code on Twitter, Facebook and Tumblr
Chris Distefano & Carly Aquilino Explain How They Started Dating, Kinda
10 Pairs Of Women's Underwear With Red Flags
5 Ways To Convince Your Girlfriend To Watch Porn